Showing posts with label African National Congress. Show all posts
Showing posts with label African National Congress. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Cape Town takes centre stage in the national conversation

Bookmark and Share

13 Jan 2015 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

The City of Cape Town seems to have taken centre stage in the national conversation since early this month, writes Tony Leon

IN THE shadow of the Charlie Hebdo slaughter in Paris, where crazed and violent fundamentalism reminds us of the fragility of the freedoms we too often take for granted, it seems trite to turn attention to more local matters.

But, in counting new year blessings and reminding ourselves of so many points that divide the often fissiparous South African society, it is pertinent perhaps that, despite the occasional pig’s head tossed into Woolworths, most religious communities in this country actually coexist in conditions of amity. If you look across the Middle East and now into the heart of Europe, and even at the cultural wars often revved up at election time in the US, this achievement is bigger than it often seems.

And we don’t coexist in conditions of religious freedom and acceptance simply because someone at Kempton Park more than 20 years ago decided it was a nice-to-have in the constitution, but because degrees of tolerance not confined just to religious coexistence are more hard-wired into our communal DNA than often appears in the daily discourse that seethes with apparent dissent and mutual recrimination.

Now on to matters of more immediate concern: the late, great Harry Oppenheimer once commented that "the difference between our two major cities is that in Johannesburg there is nothing to see, and in Cape Town there is no one to talk to".

Of course, matters have changed in more recent times as Cape Town seemed to take centre stage in the national conversation since early this month.

On the opposition side of the fence, in the only province controlled by it, Democratic Alliance (DA) leader and Western Cape Premier Helen Zille shocked her party by sacking her deputy provincial leader, Theuns Botha, from his powerful post as health MEC. In truth only the portfolios of health and education, alongside finance, amount to any budgetary and political significance in our nugatory provincial setup.

Exiling Botha, the previous Western Cape leader, to the wasteland of sport and recreation is pregnant with meaning, yet to be explained.

Predictably, the African National Congress (ANC) found much to moan about when it arrived in the Mother City to reaffirm its revolutionary credentials, alongside serving champagne and Chivas Regal in its hospitality suites.

The outpourings of ruling party bile and vitriol against the DA in Cape Town perhaps obscured the fact that, objectively viewed, and with thousands voting every year with their feet, the poor and the marginalised have a better chance of being better off in the Western Cape than in the neighbouring Eastern Cape. There many of the services are in an advanced state of collapse and atrophy. Ironically, it is the department of health here, the very portfolio from which Botha was ejected on new year ’s eve, that only three months ago won the award for the best performing in the Western Cape.

As for President Jacob Zuma’s claim that the DA cares only about "the whites" and the province is "governed by the wrong people", this is a decidedly odd statement for the president of the whole country and someone who constantly bangs on, as recently as in his New Year statement, that SA’s democratic credentials are unassailable. The province is governed by the "wrong people" precisely because the majority of them chose the "wrong" provincial government.

And when the "wrong people" in the form of the many ratepayers eye their monthly rates and services bills from the city council, they note with some consternation the very steep charges in the municipal accounts. And this is not to pour the proceeds into the leafy suburbs where the DA vote can be weighed rather than counted. But it is the result of perhaps, outside the city of Durban, the most aggressively redistributionist administration in the country. Despite the city channelling most of its funds into the townships, the ruling DA receives very few votes from its black residents in return.

Ironically, the party does much better in the townships of Johannesburg, where it has no power or patronage to parcel out. Perhaps it’s a case of what Karl Marx called "false consciousness". But then again, looking for consistency in local politics strains the imagination, if not the memory.

For example, giving equal voice to the grievance lobby in the run-up to the ANC’s 103rd anniversary bash in Cape Town was its dial-a-quote secretary-general, Gwede Mantashe. He added to the new year festive cheer by reclaiming the Freedom Charter for the ANC, in the 60th year since the document was published. Mantashe expressed his displeasure that "every Jack and Jill" (doubtless code for "Helen") and "hooligans" (not a stretch to transpose the Economic Freedom Fighters here) had wrenched the document from its rightful owners.

Back in 1995, the golden age of our Parliament as some describe it, an almighty fuss arose when the opposition challenged the fact that state funds were to be spent on the 40th anniversary of the Freedom Charter in Kliptown. Democratic Party chief whip Douglas Gibson was roasted by ANC luminaries, the voluble Kader Asmal at the fore, for daring to suggest that the Freedom Charter was a "party pamphlet".

Admittedly, the riot police were not called in to still this debate. But Asmal and other ruling party heavies were incandescent with anger at the suggestion that the document was anything other than a revered statement of national aspiration, way beyond the confines of petty party politics.

Twenty years on, and facing pressures on several fronts, and disappointment and open dissent in its ranks, present needs suggest that Gibson was more right than he ever imagined back then.

But conversations aplenty were also to be had in the quieter corners of Cape Town during the festive season.

The arrival back on these shores, temporarily at least, of so many successful South Africans, some of whom have become masters of the financial universe and corporate boardrooms across the globe, certainly improved the dialogue in ways of which Oppenheimer would certainly approve.

I was seated across the table from one such eminence, a senior executive at Eskom before democracy arrived, who then went out into the world and capped his corporate success by launching a hugely successful resource enterprise. Now he heads a significant fund overseas. Like many other temporary returnees, he remains passionately committed to this country’s success.

He kept the dinner riveted by not only crisply diagnosing the travails of our once mighty electricity provider but also suggesting a highly imaginative and cost-effective solution for this crippled giant. And it’s not just dinners by candlelight and shopping centres plunged into darkness that Eskom’s power outages forces upon us. As Brian Kantor of Investec described it a few weeks ago: "Eskom is the Grinch that stole Christmas." Because the one competitive advantage that could cause a surge in much-needed growth is the collapsing price of crude oil. But without sufficient and reliable energy supply, we cannot export our way out of economic difficulty.

After listening to the explanation about putting Eskom to rights, I asked the dinner guest whether he would, if asked by the government, return to do his national service by taking the helm at Eskom. "I absolutely would," he said. Perhaps if Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa, now charged with rescuing this key state enterprise, wants an interesting and rewarding conversation, he might give him a call.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

New speaker is not known for her impartiality

27 May 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive
If past performance is any guide to future conduct, diminished expectations are in order for the new Parliament, writes Tony Leon

Baleka Mbete, national chairwoman of the ANC
ONE of the bitchiest pieces of repartee in show business, between the acclaimed lyricist of My Fair Lady, Alan Jay Lerner, and musical supremo Andrew Lloyd Webber apparently went along the following lines: "Alan, why do people always take an instant dislike to me?" asked Lloyd Webber. "Saves time," Lerner responded.

Perhaps the fact that Baleka Mbete has a beautiful singing voice brought this conversation to mind on hearing of her recall last week to the speaker’s chair in Parliament. But more in point is that it will certainly save time and distance to bring the writ and fist of the African National Congress (ANC) and its Luthuli House headquarters to Parliament rather than the other way around.

Towards the end of the recent elections, it was reported — and not denied — that departing speaker Max Sisulu, a person of considerable standing and experience and of some independence, was "summonsed" to Luthuli House to "explain himself" in regard to his acquiescence to an opposition request that an ad hoc committee be appointed to determine Parliament’s response to the public protector’s report on Nkandla.

According to the constitution, the National Assembly over which the speaker presides is charged with "providing a national forum for public consideration of issues" and "scrutinising and overseeing executive action".

Yet Mbete is deeply conflicted from the start: she intends to be both national chairwoman of the ANC and speaker of the National Assembly. In the new Parliament, more than a dozen non-ANC parties seek the protection of the speaker to advance their interests and rights and to hold the very executive, of whose inner councils she is such a leading member, to account. Don’t expect too much scrutiny and oversight on her watch.

But then, for Mbete, this is all rather familiar territory. Before she had risen to the very apex of power in the ruling party, she presided as speaker of Parliament from 2004 until 2008. Yet, ironically, although Mbete joined in the party firing squad that politically assassinated Thabo Mbeki, she also helped his presidency close down Parliament as a centre of rigorous political contestation and scrutinising the executive.

I recall, in the first iteration of Mbete’s speakership, that she was summoned to the post as a sudden and unexplained replacement for the serving speaker, Frene Ginwala. Ginwala had provided Parliament with some lustre, and aside from her involvement in the parliamentary cover-up of the arms deal scandal, proved to be fairly independent. She later advised that she first heard of her axing on the radio, en route to a caucus meeting.

Helen Suzman, described by the man after whom the ANC headquarters are named, Chief Albert Luthuli, as "a bright star in a dark chamber", recalled that her impressive solo performance in the apartheid Parliament was made possible only by the impeccable behaviour and protection she received from the arch-conservative speaker, Henning Klopper. As she put it: "Our political convictions were miles apart. (But) he used to say to me at the beginning of each session: ‘I don’t agree with a word you say, Helen, but it is your right to say it and it is my duty to see that you enjoy that right’ — and he certainly did!"

Ironically, although there are now 88 more voices in Parliament echoing some of the sentiments once articulated alone by Suzman, they should not, all these decades later and even under a democratic constitution, expect such consideration as she enjoyed.

Two clues, of many that Mbete’s previous speakership salted back then, are hardly encouraging for the new Parliament. In September 2007, the nation was transfixed on the state of, and circumstances surrounding, the new liver acquired by then health minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang. The Sunday Times then revealed that she had been convicted of theft in 1976 while employed at a hospital in Botswana. An intrepid parliamentary colleague, Mike Waters, asked a written parliamentary question: had she ever disclosed this conviction to Mbeki? Less than an hour before the question was due to be answered in Parliament, Waters received a call from Mbete’s office advising him that the speaker had ruled the question "out of order" for containing "offensive and unbecoming language" in transgression of Parliament’s rules. When Waters stood up in Parliament to protest that the speaker was "covering up for a thief", he was suspended for five days from the house.

But it was also during Mbete’s first speakership that thievery caught hold of Parliament itself, which was defrauded of more than R36m of public money, when hundreds of MPs were investigated in the "Travelgate" scandal. In contrast with the speed with which Mbete acted against Waters, the investigation of this great stain on her watch was characterised by foot-dragging and worse.

If past performance is any guide in these matters to future conduct, diminished expectations are in order for the new Parliament.

• Leon is the author of Opposite Mandela (Jonathan Ball) Follow him on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA

 

 



Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Don’t feed a gossip fire, try to starve it of oxygen

Bookmark and Share

20 May 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

 
The furious pushback by the DA does not advance the party’s cause or the interests of its voters who so recently placed 4-million votes behind it, writes Tony Leon

THE Saturday morning after the 2004 election results were posted, I was rather tired and was enjoying an unaccustomed lie-in.

The Democratic Alliance (DA) had — in the teeth of the fiercest opposition infighting, the newly arrived Independent Democrats on its left, the vengeful New National Party on its right, and the huge African National Congress everywhere else — posted a creditable result and increased its support from five years earlier.

Any relief I felt evaporated when I reached the op-ed page of the Weekend Argus. It was dominated by an article under a large headline saying "Tony Leon must go". I seethed with indignation at its unfairness, especially when the article quoted several unnamed "party sources and insiders" who had fed this particular narrative, suggesting the party had reached the end of its road under my leadership. I was tempted to dash off an immediate response.

Before I reacted in fury, I sought the counsel of two people I could rely on for unvarnished advice, chief whip Douglas Gibson and strategist Ryan Coetzee. Both provided a context to the article and stayed my hand. Gibson, not for the first time, counselled: "Don’t feed a fire started by others, it will only spread; better, starve it of oxygen."

Coetzee pointed out that the two journalists, pens dipped in a combination of bile and vitriol, were "deeply embedded in the African National Congress (ANC)". I took their advice and someone lower down the party food chain was deputed to pen a replying, but subdued, letter and set out the objective facts, as we perceived them.

Just how embedded those journalists were would be revealed in the "cash for articles" scandal that engulfed the Independent Newspapers group, and the authors of this hatchet job were revealed to be in the pay of the ANC premier of the Western Cape, Ebrahim Rasool, and were forced to leave their posts before I left mine about three years later.

Last weekend, instead of savouring their sweeping victory at the polls, the ANC’s elections head, Malusi Gigaba, vengefully turned on the media: "You campaigned hard against the ANC and we beat you. We defeated you," he harrumphed. On Saturday, at the Franschhoek Literary Festival, veteran journalist Max du Preez pointed out that, during the election, the ANC had the fawning and opposition-censoring South African Broadcasting Corporation in its corner, plus the support of a Gupta-owned newspaper (The New Age) and TV channel (ANN7), and a self-acknowledged ANC supporter in charge of all Independent Newspapers titles. In reality, the ANC had "beaten just three or four newspapers: Business Day, Sunday Times, City Press and the Mail & Guardian". "They totally ignore the Afrikaans press," he added.

These past two Sunday mornings have been excruciating for DA leader Helen Zille. After just 72 hours of positive reporting on her and the party after their impressive election result, parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko dropped a bomb by announcing in the Sunday Times that she was departing from her post and these shores to continue her education. Barely a day later, former DA insider Gareth van Onselen penned an acidic column on the "real reasons" for Mazibuko’s departure and fingered Zille for it.

Just as that report and the furious pushback by the DA against Van Onselen subsided, another even more thermonuclear device was detonated in last Sunday’s newspaper. The Sunday Times led with the headline: "Mazibuko nothing without me — Zille". The report culled various leaks from the small (fewer than 30 members) party federal executive meeting, which suggested that Zille had launched a root-and-branch attack at the meeting on her former protégé, Mazibuko.

Within hours, Zille had published a special edition of her newsletter under the headline, "The abuse of media to drive internal agendas in the DA." She provided a blow-by-blow version of her recollection of the meeting, which she said had been distorted by the Sunday Times to advance "the succession agendas" of certain unnamed party leaders. Let me add that the reporter concerned, Jan-Jan Joubert, does not practise "cash for articles" or any other unethical versions of journalism.

None of this is pretty, and none of it advances the party cause or the interests of its voters who so recently placed 4-million votes behind it. Nor does it do anything to help the cause of the new parliamentary leader, who will take over in what are now the most difficult of circumstances.

I am not sure that seeking meetings with newspaper editors to change the narrative or expose the agendas, or whatever, will really do much to staunch the leaks, an age-old phenomenon which Zille herself, as a political journalist in the 1970s and 1980s, benefited from in her own reportage.

Rather, heed the advice of Tony Blair to his fractious, but electorally successful, Labour Party: "When you look inside you lose, when you look outside you win."

• Leon is the author of Opposite Mandela (Jonathan Ball) Follow him on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA

Tuesday, April 15, 2014

ANC fights on against its worst enemy: business

Bookmark and Share

15 Apr 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

The acquiescence of the National Planning Commission as its plan dies a slow death is strange, writes Tony Leon

IN APRIL 1962, President John F Kennedy, at a dinner he hosted for the then living Nobel Prize winners of the western hemisphere, said: "I think this is the most extraordinary collection of talent, of human knowledge, that has ever been gathered at the White House, with the possible exception of when Thomas Jefferson dined alone."

Jefferson, the third US president, had an extraordinary and wide-ranging intellect. He left to posterity many aphorisms that seem far more contemporary than when they were written more than 230 years ago.

For example, he wrote: "When people fear the government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty." Just how much South Africa’s ruling party has to fear from the people will be revealed when the votes are counted after May 7. If opinion polls are accurate, it need not fear much at all.

For South Africa’s private sector, a different set of expectations applies, and the verdict against it has already been delivered, apparently.

It is the enemy, or at least that section of it that has not submitted to the government’s itch to control it.

Anthea Jeffery of the South African Institute of Race Relations has produced research that examined 11 items of legislation in immaculate detail — from tightened rules for black empowerment to controls over mining and offshore gas and oil exploration to mandatory gender quotas for the boardroom and reduced protection for foreign investors and local property owners. She headlined her research, "the ANC government’s war on economic rationality". The Economist magazine — presumably well read by the foreign investors desperately needed to realise the National Development Plan’s vision of 5.4% economic growth, as opposed to our less-than-2% present growth path — weighed in.

Its verdict was harsh, but accurate. Last week, it opined: "These business-bashing bills are part of an ominous trend … the common thread is that they weaken property rights, reduce private sector autonomy, threaten business with draconian penalties and undermine investor confidence."

Undeterred by any such warnings, two weeks ago, the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform made its own contribution to this heady brew. It proposes that all farmers (or the fewer than 40,000 large-scale commercial farmers remaining) will be required to hand over 50% of their farmland to their workers. Never mind the constitution and food security, the real deal here was the process followed in this "final policy proposal" or, in this case, not followed.

At the weekend, I met one of South Africa’s largest and most politically progressive farm owners. Like other more thoughtful members of his tribe, he told me the department had engaged with him and other farm owners and they, in turn, had made very significant proposals to create a more just land order in South Africa. "And," he advised, "when the department published their new proposals, not a single item had been changed from the original draft."

More or less exactly the same happened to the oil and gas provisions, despite the lengthy process of parliamentary engagement, of the controversial Minerals and Petroleum Resource Development Amendment Bill (disclosure: I consult in this sector).

On this page recently, Rhodes University’s Gavin Keeton pointed to a striking fact: South Africa’s still relatively good standing in the international benchmarked global competitiveness index is almost entirely attributable to the "spectacular performance" of the private sector’s contribution to it and, conversely, is weighed down by the underperformance of our public sector, other than the Treasury and the Reserve Bank. And then along comes Public Enterprises Minister Malusi Gigaba, whose only regret is that the government ever privatised anything! Go figure this one out.

But competing for space in the parallel universe, heedless of how the real world really works, up comes African National Congress secretary-general Gwede Mantashe. He informed a business gathering last week that the government’s solution for small business was to create a new ministry. As if the installation of yet another layer of bureaucracy will assist. As Clem Sunter, who knows something about the practice of business and the scenarios for a better future, archly noted: "In most countries, a red carpet is rolled out for investors. In South Africa, we roll out the red tape."

As for the much commented-upon loud silence of South Africa’s business leadership as its interests get trampled in the dust of the legislative and regulatory steamroller, perhaps the fact that more than 60% of the top JSE-listed firms earn most of their revenue offshore provides an explanation. The acquiescence of the members of the National Planning Commission as its plan dies a slow death by a thousand cuts of legislation and regulation is stranger. If we do not have a clear explanation for the silence of these lambs, Jefferson at least left us a warning. He said: "All tyranny needs to do to gain a foothold is for people of good conscience to remain silent."

• Follow Tony Leon on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA

 

 

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Fast food chain is a sign of peace in our time

Bookmark and Share

08 Apr 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

The presence of fast-food hamburgers tells us more about our national economic and political wellbeing than we might think, writes Tony Leon

WHAT does the presence of fast-food hamburgers, specifically the Big Mac, tell us about our national economic and political wellbeing?

More than you might think. An item in the Washington Post at the weekend caught my attention. It reported that the three McDonald’s restaurants in Crimea, recently "abruptly annexed by Russia", are now closed. The Ukrainian McDonald’s branch said the closure was for "technical reasons" — although, as the reporter waspishly noted, this was "perhaps referring to the difficulty of supplying your restaurants when they turn up in a foreign country overnight". And the closure appears permanent as McDonald’s has offered to move its Crimean employees to other jobs in Ukraine and has thrown in three months’ free rental for good measure.

When I retweeted this nugget, if you’ll forgive the fast-food pun, one Struan Lloyd responded: "They should close everywhere — no nutrients." My former colleague, Douglas Gibson, suggested Crimeans could now "eat Russian sausage instead".

I was immediately reminded of something else entirely. In 1999, when globalisation was the new big thing and Russian expansionism appeared at an end, the influential polemicist Thomas Friedman published a fat book on the subject, The Lexus and the Olive Tree. I was impressed with its take on the unprecedented integration of finance, markets, nation states and technology and his account of how a new international order was replacing the Cold War order.

Some of Friedman’s assumptions have been proven wrong, not the least his underestimation of the rise of Cold War warrior Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin. But one, at least, has been triumphantly vindicated, as the weekend disappearance of the Big Mac from Crimean menus proves.

Friedman devotes a chapter to "The Golden Arches Theory of Conflict Prevention". Having travelled the world back then and munched hamburgers throughout, he came to a fascinating, if somewhat indigestible, conclusion: "No two countries that both had McDonald’s had fought a war against each other since each got its McDonald’s."

He even tested this idea with executives at (I am not kidding) "Hamburger University", McDonald’s research and training facility in Oakbrook, Illinois. They confirmed his thesis, that "when a country reaches the level of economic development where it has a middle class big enough to support a McDonald’s network, it becomes a McDonald’s country. And people in McDonald’s countries don’t like to fight wars anymore, they prefer to wait in line for burgers."

Crimea is an imperfect fit for this thesis, but it roughly works. The closure of the burger chain happened there after the forcible annexation by Russia, but it broadly suggests that peace is the prerequisite for the continued existence of the golden arches.

One of the postapartheid dividends was the arrival of the Big Mac in South Africa in November 1995, only after the first democratic election and South Africa had bedded down its new constitutional order.

The company’s website says the roll-out — we are approaching our 200th McDonald’s store — had been unprecedented, with 30 stores opened in a record 23 months. Of some interest, and undoubtedly useful for his pension pot, is that African National Congress supremo Cyril Ramaphosa has been, since March 2011, the development licensee here driving its expansion. If he has as much success in harvesting votes as in his investment in flipping burgers, then perhaps his party will do better next month than predicted.

With the weekend news that the Nigerian economy has overtaken South Africa’s as Africa’s largest, I decided to apply Friedman’s thesis to this country of 169-million people.

There is not a single McDonald’s in Nigeria. According to McDonald’s CEO Don Thompson, the company was only now "looking at Nigeria".

Perhaps this underscores how not just fast foods but also national statistics should be accompanied with a giant health warning. For Nigeria relies almost entirely for its economic wellbeing, or at least for 80% of government revenue, on its vast oil resources.

And the recent forced departure of its central bank chief, Lamido Sanusi, by President Goodluck Jonathan, tells its own sorry tale. He was fired, essentially, for presenting to parliament evidence that more than $20bn had gone missing from the state oil company, and that a figure close to the president was a suspect in this misappropriation.

So, for South Africa, our addiction to fast food triggers both health and economic warnings. On Monday, Peter Bruce eloquently explained our chronic dependence on foreign investment, and Business Day’s editorial was a baleful reminder that we can’t consume and spend our way out of our economic difficulty. Still, when you next see the golden arches of McDonald’s, it’s worth remembering they are evidence of our peace dividend.


• Follow Tony Leon on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA

 

 

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Cold War tension in land of my grandmother

Bookmark and Share

04 Mar 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

Russia’s excuse is the defence of minority rights. The Crimea, demographically, is a sort of Western Cape of the Ukraine, writes Tony Leon
Pro-Russian protesters with Russian flags take part in a rally in central Donetsk on Saturday


IN SEPTEMBER 2006, long before the Russian president had broken his own country’s new democracy or thought of invading his near neighbours, Vladimir Putin paid a visit to our Parliament. Perhaps to make a point about the genuine multiparty outfit she presided over, then speaker Baleka Mbete included some opposition figures along with the African National Congress (ANC) heavyweights in a parliamentary tea party she hosted for Putin.

The enigmatic Russian president nodded politely and mostly without comment as the ANC members expressed great appreciation for the "significant role" the USSR had played in the "struggle for the liberation of SA".

As I awaited my turn to exchange conversational niceties with the president in our midst, I dismissed my first thought as somewhat undiplomatic: that, in fact, it was the fall of communism in Eastern Europe that emboldened the reform process in South Africa, initially at the hand of FW de Klerk, and that those seated around Putin were the beneficiaries of that singular moment in history back in 1989.

So when my turn came, I sought the safer topic of my family’s geography and their arrival on these shores back in the late 19th century. I advised the president, with some certainty, that I could claim to be the only South African present who could lay claim to a Russian grandmother!

Putin responded with apparent interest via his interpreter, and asked where in Russia my grandmother’s family originated. I answered: "From Sevastopol in the Crimea." The intense and ultra-polite Putin then put me to rights when he deadpanned: "Crimea is no longer part of Mother Russia, but is now part of the Ukraine."

The cascading crisis in Ukraine, and in particular in the Crimean peninsula, this past week suggests that it is possible that the borders of one of the most contested countries in Europe, if not the world, perched as it is between the eastern borders of Russia and the democratic nations of the European Union (EU), could be redrawn again. And military force has already been deployed by Russia in the largest of the former Soviet republics outside Russia.

Whether this will lead to a reigniting of the Cold War or to a new chapter in the storybook of 1989’s more or less peaceful democratic revolution in the satellites of the old Soviet Union remains deeply uncertain.

Events in faraway Ukraine should resonate deeply over here, even as we preoccupy ourselves with such matters as the Oscar Pistorius trial, which, to be fair, will engross most of the watching world.

By ideological inclination, and joined as we are through Brics and apparent nuclear power deals and the very history my parliamentary colleagues related to Putin eight years ago, South Africa tilts toward Moscow. Then again, the EU is our largest trading partner and the struggle for democracy here in many ways mirrors the demands of the protesters in Kiev who toppled their corrupt and increasingly despotic president, Viktor Yanukovych, last week. Putin’s geostrategic interest lies in securing the Black Sea naval bases Russia leases in Crimea from Ukraine and in preventing the country’s drift from Moscow’s orbit into the West, where the heart of Kiev’s new leadership apparently lies. But, in an ironic twist (for South Africa’s majoritarian government), the excuse Moscow has provided for its actions is the defence of minority rights. The Crimea, demographically, is a sort of Western Cape of the Ukraine. Its population is 60% ethnic Russian but this group forms only one-sixth of the population of Ukraine.

But it is in the universal realm of so-called democratic deepening that the relevant analogy between South Africa and Ukraine and other startup democracies is located. Back in 1991, when South Africa was negotiating its democratic constitution, Ukraine peacefully separated from the Soviet Union and, like us, gave up its nuclear capability. Its first democratic elections went well, then badly, and a people-inspired "Orange Revolution" in 2004 appeared to reset it on a democratic course. But since then — in the words of the Financial Times — "the country has been led by a cynical, corrupt leadership that has taken Ukraine today to the brink of economic meltdown".

There’s a growing and depressingly lengthening list of countries where the democratic wave was accompanied by a deep authoritarian undertow. Think of Egypt recently and Russia itself over the past decade, to mention two stand-out examples. South Africa, despite more than 3,000 protests in the past three months, maintains its democratic stance. But even we, in the words of this week’s Economist survey, have joined the ranks of "some recent recruits to the democratic camp (that) have lost their lustre".

Our next election will be only a part of regaining our democratic sheen. It’s what comes afterwards in reinvigorating our independent institutions and reanimating the checks and balances on an overreaching state that will sustain us for the long haul.
 
• Leon is the author of The Accidental Ambassador (Pan Macmillan). Follow him on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA
 
 

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Mandela’s audience more forgiving than Gordhan’s

Bookmark and Share

25 Feb 2014 | Tony Leon  | Original Publication:  BDlive

Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan has to reassure a much wider audience in his budget speech, writes Tony Leon

MORE than 30 years ago, then US secretary of state Henry Kissinger asked a famous question about whom he should speak to if the world caught fire: "Who do I call if I want to call Europe?"

Economically speaking, at the democratic dawn of South Africa in June 1994, then president Nelson Mandela knew exactly who to call when he needed to obtain the buy-in of the local business community.

Mandela surprised guests at the first banquet he hosted for a visiting head of state, France’s François Mitterrand, by retiring after the first course. It became known only the next day that his early departure was occasioned by the need to make four or so telephone calls. He wished to inform Anglo American’s Harry Oppenheimer, Sanlam’s Marinus Daling, Rembrandt’s Anton Rupert and Liberty’s Donald Gordon that his finance minister, Derek Keys, would announce his retirement the next morning and that the government intended to appoint Nedbank’s Chris Liebenberg in his place.
Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, delivers his budget speech on behalf of the Treasury in May last year.


That vignette tells us a lot about the South Africa of 20 years ago: the economic power was overwhelmingly and tightly held by four or so megacorporations, all led by white men, and that the first black head of government, so serenely self-confident with his sure touches and grand gestures, still needed the stamp of approval from outside the government in an economic realm quite outside its control back then. Undoubtedly the government thought that replacing one business titan from outside politics — although, very notionally, Keys was a National Party member appointed by FW de Klerk — with another respected leader from the private sector in the form of banker Liebenberg, would quieten the markets, which indeed it did.

There was good reason for the first African National Congress (ANC) government’s deference to business and the market-makers. Its election manifesto consisted of large promises embedded in its Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP), but the reality on entering office spoke of a different universe. One of Mandela’s biographers, Martin Meredith, provided a sombre snapshot of the situation: "Mandela discovered that South Africa’s economy was in dire straits. The ANC expected to inherit an economic cornucopia; its ambitious development plans were based on that notion. But the coffers … were nearly empty."

The RDP might have been inspired by the red glow of socialist thinking but it was the country’s balance sheets that were truly red: the previous government had run up a record budget deficit of 8.6% of gross domestic product (GDP) and gross foreign reserves had fallen to less than the equivalent of three weeks’ worth of imports.

Proving that even the most ideologically inspired administration could be pragmatic and adaptive, then transport minister Mac Maharaj, a communist, explained the limits of the new reality: "There was simply no money to do what we had planned…. We had to dump our plans and start from the beginning."

Longer in the tooth, Maharaj today presides over President Jacob Zuma’s spin operation and is much involved in drafting his major speeches. Strange, then, that in his response to the state of the nation debate last week, Zuma said the number of black people in senior management, at more than 40%, was "not enough". In terms of simple quantitative ethnic transformation, it’s a remarkable turnaround. But, as Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan might reveal in the subtext of his budget speech on Wednesday, there are real limits in pumping up the demand side, while the supply side issues are not addressed.

But as Investec Group chief economist Annabel Bishop noted in her budget preview, the lower than estimated fiscal deficit, expected to come in at about 4% of GDP, could be the standout item of good news, and this, more than cosy phone calls, could quieten the restive and increasingly alienated investor community.

Because while the makeup and control of our economy has undergone a dramatic change, an iron law, which dates back more than 100 years or more in South Africa — remains true: with low rates of domestic saving (at just 16% of GDP, half the figure set by the National Planning Commission and last attained here more than 30 years ago), we remain reliant, ever more so these days, on foreign investment, crucially short-term flows to fund the deficit. And then there are those pesky rating agencies, which are unsentimental or uninterested in racial bean-counting when determining the sovereign’s creditworthiness, and thus its borrowing costs.

Gordhan has had his work cut out for him — to fund an expensive public sector wage bill, an expanding welfare state funded by a relatively tiny tax base of just more than 6-million personal income taxpayers.

So while Zuma had the luxury last week of addressing a domestic constituency, Gordhan has to reassure a much wider and less forgiving audience on Wednesday.

• Leon is the author of The Accidental Ambassador (Pan Macmillan). Follow him on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA

 


Tuesday, January 21, 2014

DA faces ANC in a changed environment

Bookmark and Share

21 Jan 2014 | Tony Leon | Original Publication:  BDlive

It was the events around and after the memorial service and funeral for former president Nelson Mandela that revealed a changed reality in South Africa, writes Tony Leon

ENGLISH soccer great Gary Lineker once observed that "football is a simple game. Twenty-two men chase a ball for 90 minutes and, at the end, the Germans always win."

Give or take the ascendancy of Spain and one or two others in soccer, this seems to be a handy user’s guide for watching the unfolding general election campaign in South Africa, and predicting its final outcome.

In horse-racing terms, the African National Congress (ANC) is a dead cert to win nationally, and odds-on favourite to retain its grip on eight of nine provinces.

Gauteng has been put in play through a combination of factors — a fractious ruling party, extremely unpopular e-tolls and spiralling delivery failures, and the energetic and fresh-faced campaign of the Democratic Alliance’s (DA’s) top candidate, Mmusi Maimane. But even Maimane, the new hope for the opposition, perhaps realises how long the odds are in reality.

In the previous provincial poll in 2009, the ANC obtained 63.99% of the vote, a shade higher than it achieved in the home province of President Jacob Zuma in KwaZulu-Natal.

Even dreams of the opposition combining to force the ANC below 50% in Gauteng must yield to the reality that as far as co-operation between, for example, the DA and the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) goes, there is, as the meretricious Julius Malema would say, "no way, Madam". Perhaps this caution explains why Maimane himself has apparently taken a two-way bet on the outcome and reserved a place for himself on the DA’s list for Parliament as a form of electoral insurance.

But, of course, beneath the predicted headline outcome, a great deal of the small print in the results will also set the course of our political economy for years to come.

It was the events around and after the memorial service and funeral last month for former president Nelson Mandela that revealed a changed reality in South Africa.

There is no doubt that, in life, Mandela had a significant regard for Zuma.

Back in September 2002, when Zuma was still deputy president and had been obliged by the guardians around President Thabo Mbeki to issue a statement saying he had no ambition to become president, Mandela told me — and doubtless others: "JZ is the key man in the party and the movement."

I thought at the time that this showed the great Madiba to be startlingly out of touch with the national zeitgeist.

Events proved just how canny the old man actually was.

Even in death, Mandela’s touch seemed to advance Zuma further.

On December 5 last year, the ANC was due to commence a difficult national executive meeting at the very moment when Nkandla and the serial scandals around it were raising serious internal questions about the party’s president. Mandela’s passing rewrote the timetable.

It was also a moment for the country and the world to perhaps embrace the leader who stood in Mandela’s stead.

But as The Economist noted, even before the cascade of debacles at the FNB Stadium: "Without the protection of Mandela’s saintly aura" the ruling party and its leaders "will be more harshly judged".

Just how quickly the mantle proved to be nontransferable was revealed when sections of the crowd at the FNB Stadium booed the president, a moment of exquisite personal embarrassment and national shame.

But it might be of (cold) comfort for the president to know that he is not alone in this unhappy league.

I witnessed then-Australian prime minister John Howard being raucously jeered at a packed rugby stadium in Sydney, in September 2001, at the Bledisloe Cup rugby grand finale.

Tony Blair was roundly booed by 10,000 people at a women’s institute conference in London in 2000.

Although neither of them then used national security agents to filter future crowds, both Howard and Blair went on to win hefty majorities at the next elections.

By our standards of glorifying regnant leaders, the FNB Stadium wake-up call signalled the arrival of more normal and less deified politics on our shores.

Barely had Mandela been laid to rest in Qunu than the ANC’s most powerful trade union partner, the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa, chose to announce its disaffiliation from the ruling party.

The iron unity of old is now more of a circular firing squad.

All this uncivil chatter and churn leads to the central question that remains unresolved: will the ANC be returned with a total greater or less than 60%?

More on this, anon.
• Leon is the author of The Accidental Ambassador (Pan Macmillan). Follow him on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA OR on Facebook: facebook.com/TonyLeonSA