Showing posts with label SAA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SAA. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Local leaders at risk of failing Berlusconi test

Bookmark and Share

30 Oct 2012 | Tony Leon | Original Publication: BDlive

We have advanced down the road where know-who rather than know-how is the price of admission to corporate riches, writes Tony Leon

ON FRIDAY, Silvio Berlusconi, Italy’s former prime minister, was sentenced to four years’ imprisonment for tax fraud. The more sensational of his trials — allegedly paying "Ruby the heart-stealer", an underage dancer, for sex and then abusing his position to secure her release — still lies ahead.

South Africans will be familiar with this trope: the lurid intersection of public office, abuse of position and problems with the taxman. Earlier this year, Berlusconi opined that "political credibility is like virginity — easy to lose, difficult to maintain and impossible to regain if lost".

A number of South African politicians — serving and aspiring — are currently in the dock of public opinion on issues of credibility. In the recessionary world, reputation management and how to repair damaged credibility is a growth industry, and in South Africa there is no shortage of clients.

First in the line-up is Cyril Ramaphosa, Lonmin director and a favoured deputy presidential candidate, according to some in the camp of President Jacob Zuma. The Prince Hamlet of the African National Congress is accused, based on e-mails he wrote to fellow Lonmin executives on the eve of the Marikana mine massacre, of being "complicit in mass murder". Sunday Times editor Ray Hartley did a suitable demolition job on the accusation and on advocate Dali Mpofu, who advanced it. He described this characterisation as "an absurd and slanderous lie". But it was a less sensational communication from Ramaphosa that compels attention and invites unease, even if in the tangled web of political influence-peddling by impeccably connected businessmen it causes little surprise.

In an e-mail to Lonmin chairman Roger Phillimore about the conduct and lack of action by Mineral Resources Minister Susan Shabangu, Ramaphosa advises "we should have a discussion (with her) to see what she needs to do". The idea that a company director can tell a minister "what to do" underlines how far we have advanced down the road where "know-who" rather than "know-how" is the price of admission to corporate advancement and riches.

South Africa is perhaps an extreme example of this tendency but it hardly stands alone. Even in the US, where generally (see Mitt Romney) success in business is the prologue to political office and not the reverse, we have the case of Dick Cheney, the veritable Darth Vader of modern politics. Before he crossed to the "dark side" of approving waterboarding and other torture exotica as state policy when vice-president, he was CEO and chairman of energy giant Halliburton. But his appointment to corporate office was based entirely on his impeccable political connectivity, having served in the administrations of presidents Gerald Ford and George Bush and then for 20 years in Congress.

Next in the field of evolving local reputations is Mamphela Ramphele. An avatar of good governance, harsh critic of government corruption, apostle of transparency and, on some accounts, an aspiring political leader, she is also chairwoman of Gold Fields. The company is currently in the frame with a controversial black economic empowerment deal concerning one of South Africa’s richest mines, South Deep. Some dodgy characters and powerful politicians were included in this bonanza. Her somewhat lame response to a Financial Mail inquiry — "I was not part of the decision-making at the time" — might be technically true, but hardly inspires confidence about shouldering responsibility or sweeping out the Augean stables of the political influence-peddling of which, in other contexts, she loudly complains.

Finally we have Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan. Of a dozen or so Cabinet ministers I shepherded around Argentina during my diplomatic stint there, he probably did most to advance South Africa’s international image. This was not because some of his colleagues underperformed during their visits. Rather, it was due to his credibility as a thoughtful steward of public finances. This proved to be sweet breath on the local air of Buenos Aires, weighed down by runaway government spending and high inflation.

In Parliament last week to present his medium-term budget policy statement, he promised to rein in government expenditure by, among other things, looking closely at the number of employees in the public sector, suggesting billions of rand could be saved by identifying "ghost and surplus workers".

His credibility test lies in making good on this promise. He needs to prove he doesn’t just sign the cheques but has the will and the power to obtain quos for the quids he dispenses. A good place for him to start would be South African Airways, for which he recently provided a further R5bn bail-out. He would do well to look up the website Avcom.co.za. It reports that SAA operates with about double the world average of employees per aircraft (957 per plane). If Gordhan does not start to make the necessary cuts he promised, he too might find he fails the Berlusconi test.

• Follow Tony Leon on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

As SA’s colours rise with SAA, so do the losses

Bookmark and Share

09 Oct 2012 | Tony Leon | Original Publication: BDlive
SAA may not just be a drag on growth but may also contribute to the widening of the current account deficit, writes Tony Leon

IN 1960, in the first ever televised US presidential debate, Richard Nixon showed up with five o’clock shadow and looked shifty compared with the uber-cool John F Kennedy; in 1988, George Bush looked at his watch during his encounter with Bill Clinton; in 2000, Al Gore sighed audibly in his TV duel against Bush’s son, George. All three went on to lose the presidential election a month or so later. On such twitches of body language the hinges of a nation, and the world’s sole, albeit declining, hyper-power would appear to turn.

Last Wednesday, in his first debate with challenger Mitt Romney, President Barack Obama posted a "subprime" performance. He looked peevish and was widely accused of being defensive and, in place of his fluid eloquence of four years before, of showing up with a grimace and "looking as though he would be rather anywhere else".

But if a different Obama showed up in Denver, so did a different Romney.

Gone was the right-wing Tea Party-appeasing hardliner. In his place was the Massachusetts moderate. It is entirely in the realm of conjecture as to which Romney will present himself in the event that he comes from behind and beats Obama next month.

When Romney was debating Ted Kennedy in their contest for the US Senate in 1994, the liberal senator killed Romney’s chances with a memorable put-down. At that time — a position he has reversed several times subsequently — on the issue of abortion, Romney proclaimed himself "prochoice". "No you’re not," snapped Kennedy, "as with everything, you’re multiple choice."

Obama never brought to the debate any of the sound and fury of his barrage of negative advertising against Romney, which portrays the Republican as a vampire capitalist job-destroyer from his time as the founder of Bain Capital, the private equity firm that netted Romney a fortune of about $250m.

There is a direct connection between Bain Capital and the continuing misfortunes of South African Airways (SAA). One of Romney’s closest associates and a co-founder of Bain Capital is the notorious Coleman Andrews, who between 1998 and 2001, pocketed R232m from the grateful and unsuspecting South African taxpayer for 20 months’ work as SAA CEO. Now, 11 years and four CEOs later, SAA has returned to the fiscus for another R5bn bail-out, this time dressed up as a "guarantee". David Gleason estimates that since 1997, the taxpayer has stumped up more than R16bn to keep the flag flying. Yesterday’s revelation that the airline’s balance sheet is far redder, to the tune of about R1.25bn in losses last year, than previously thought suggests that the ailing airline will revisit, soon enough again, the government trough.

Relax, it could be worse: in Argentina, state carrier Aerolineas Argentinas loses a whopping $2m a day, making its annualised losses about five times worse than the leaked balance sheet of SAA suggests.

The CEO of Aerolineas proclaimed with nationalist fervour: "The colours of the Argentinian flag rise with every takeoff." And, like SAA, so do the losses. I was struck on my recent flight homeward to read the remark of SAA (now former) CEO Siza Mzimela: "We will continue to be a catalyst for economic growth in SA and the rest of the continent." On current trends, SAA may not just be a drag on growth but may also contribute to the widening of the current account deficit.

All this raises the question of the role of the state in the business of owning airlines. The old Tory adage that "the business of government is not the government of business" has been upended in the wake of the financial crisis, which put the kibosh on the light-touch, low-tax regime in which the Bain Capitals of this world flourished and wreaked their trail of "creative destruction".

During my years in Argentina, when we increased the tourist arrivals from there to here by more than 100%, SAA was a vital and valued partner. So, I am forced to admit, given that its political head, Marthinus van Schalkwyk, is my political nemesis, was SA Tourism, which, in a sea of state dysfunction, is an island of professional excellence.

But neither of these facts suggests that state supervision has improved matters in government-owned entities. All of which leads back to Andrews who, in the event of a Romney win, could be a very big figure in the next US administration. In Parliament in June last year, Jeff Radebe — today in the firing line over various failures on his justice watch but who was then minister of public enterprises — memorably tore into then Transnet CEO Saki Macozoma for the multiple lapses of corporate governance around the Andrews appointment.

Macozoma, Radebe and Andrews have all moved onward and upward since then. Meanwhile, SAA and its state owner are nose-diving over the fiscal cliff and widening our national deficit, the one matter Obama did talk about last Wednesday.

• Follow Tony Leon on Twitter: @TonyLeonSA.